Showing posts with label Book Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Reviews. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

"The Red Pyramid" and "The Throne of Fire" by Rick Riordan

 I have a hard time writing separate book reviews for books that are in a series together.  So, I thought I'd give a quick review of the first two books in The Kane Chronicles trilogy, by Rick Riordan

When I first heard about Rick Riordan, it was in the Spring of 2008 (so LONG ago).  I was preparing a literature circles unit with my one Language Arts class that I had my first year of teaching.  The library at good old Landmark was huge.  It was so incredibly, nice, with a large section of books that teachers could check out for their classes to use.  One of the books that I thought looked interesting was a book called The Sea of Monsters by Riordan.  I tried to read all of the books that I had picked for the Literature Circles groups, and instead, after I finished reading The Sea of Monsters (which is actually book 2 in the series), I found books 1 and 3 and devoured them.

I am going to preface this review by saying that I have a lot of respect for Rick Riordan, not just as an author of great books, but as somebody that obviously has worked with middle school kids successfully, which is pretty rare.  I don't know of any other novelists that write with that middle school sense of humor as successfully and inventively as Riordan does. Okay, now on to the review.

Carter and Sadie Kane share narration in both of these novels.  They are brother and sister, but they don't know each other all that well since they have been separated since their mother's death when they were quite young.  Sadie, the younger of the siblings, has been stuck in boring old England with her grandparents.  She gets to see her Dad and brother on Christmas.

Carter has been living with his Dad, a prominent Archaeologist that specializes in studying Egypt and traveling the world with him.  When they pick up Sadie and head to the British Museum on Christmas to study the Rosetta Stone, they have no idea  that their lives will change so dramatically.  Carter and Sadie's father somehow releases the Egyptian God Set, and four other Egyptian Gods:  Nephythys, Osiris, Isis and Horus.

Carter and Sadie are then whisked off to Brooklyn with their Uncle Amos and told about their powerful heritage:  They have the blood of pharaohs from both their mother and their father and because of this, they start gaining interesting powers, such as the ability to fight monsters and to create portals. They have to use these new talents rather quickly, since Set has entombed their father, and it's up to them to save him and the world from Set's destruction.   They encounter several creepy Egyptian Gods and monsters while they try to defeat Set (and in the second book wake up the God Ra).  They are also hunted by the magician of the House of Life, who blame the siblings for awaking the Gods, a time-honored TABOO. 

Okay, whew.  That's a general synopsis of the entire series, and a little bit about the plot from the first book.  I don't want to spoil anymore than I already have.

Sadie and Carter take turns telling their story.  Usually Carter will take two chapters, then Sadie will write two, and they'll flip flop.  The narration in the story is what threw me off the first time I read The Red Pyramid.  I didn't like the narration, especially the contrast between the two characters.  Carter is a nerdy, well-behaved kid that was OBVIOUSLY home-schooled.  Sadie is a snarky, British girl with a punk attitude and enjoys defying orders.  The dual narration is different from the Percy books because those books are solely narrated by Percy, and I thought that Riordan was trying to hard to make them like Percy.

I am going to add in that I really like the way Riordan wrote most of the characters from this story, including: Khufu, the intelligent baboon that loves the Lakers and mercilessly beats Carter at basketball;  Uncle Amos who looks liked a mob boss with his fedora and Italian suits;  Bast, the cat God that wears a leopard print body suit and enjoys her Friskies; Anubis, the God of funerals and ceremonies for the dead, who appears as a jackal headed humanoid to most people, but whose appearance to Sadie changes into a hot, goth, human teenage boy; and last, but not least, Set, the antagonist in the first book that becomes a reluctant ally in the next book, described as wearing a red, silk disco suit.  I think part of Riordan's writing ingenuity is just the way he can adapt these Egyptian Gods to modern times. 

The second time I read The Red Pyramid, I liked it a lot better.  I embraced the differences and similarities between the two series.  Riordan's humor, will always be in his books targeted for children.  It's a part of his style, and you either love it or you hate it.  I really enjoyed the growth that Carter and Sadie's relationship had in the books.  They started out as almost strangers, and in the end, they become close friends and they learn to rely on each other.  They embrace each others differences, and in the end, they're still family, which is what matters the most.

Both characters show a lot of growth in their personalities as well, when they finally realize at the end of The Red Pyramid making the right choice, is not often the easy choice.  And I think that's a great lesson that middle school aged kids need to learn and will be able to relate to.  Their choices may not mean the end of the world as we know it, but those choices are important for the students. 

The Red Pyramid and The Throne of Fire are both fast-paced, action-comedy novels that showcase the importance of family, friendships, love, choices, and growing up.  I recommend these books starting with 5th grade and up.  The humor in them helps balance out the sad, serious issues that these characters face.  I think that most students will be able to relate to Sadie and Carter, one way or another, and I think they'll enjoy learning about each of the characters, monsters and Gods.  They're easy books to get into, especially for the more reluctant male readers that like action.  And, there's enough almost romance between Carter and Zia/ Sadie, Anubis, and Walt (2nd book) to make the girls interested as well.

I highly recommend this series to your middle school students!  Encourage them to read, read, read!

Thursday, June 16, 2011

"Sorcery and Cecelia or the Enchanted Chocolate Pot" Book Review

I am going to admit that I am biased when I review this book.  This is one of my favorite books.  Ever.  I will say that about a lot of books, but I love everything about this book!

This novel is written by two authors, Patricia C. Wrede and Caroline Stevermer.  The point of view that the authors use in this novel is a little different than most students are used to.  This book is written using letters.

The setting of this story is England in the early 1800, during the Regency period.  Most students won't know any of this, so they might be interested in learning a little bit more about the time period.  Especially those gifted kids.

There are two main characters in the story, named Cecelia (Cecy) and Kate.  They are best friends who are also cousins.  Because of an unfortunate, unladylike event involving a goat, they are separated during their Season.  Cecy is left behind in their country home, while Kate is allowed to go to London with her obnoxious sister, Georgy and overbearing aunt to come out for her Season.  The two girls write letters back and forth to each other, telling stories of their fascinating encounters and interesting adventures.

Kate comes across a little garden in the middle of a building.  While there, she meets a frightening woman who, to Kate's bewilderment, calls her Thomas.  She tries to get Kate (Thomas?) to drink scalding chocolate, that Kate clumsily spills on said scary lady and manages to escape.  A couple of evenings later, she is asked to dance by a mysterious man who tells her.  "I am Thomas" also known as the "Mysterious Marquis".  For reasons you see later, Kate and Cecy actually referring to Thomas as the "Odious Marquis".  After Kate meets Thomas, her Season is thrown into disarray, while trying to help the marquis avoid the frightening antagonist named Miranda. 

In the good old country, Cecy meets the niece of a neighbor.  Dorothea is able to catch the attention of any man she wants, like bees drawn to honey.  All she wants, however, is a simple life with a more simple boy.  Cecy, in the process of trying to help Dorothea, meets a stubborn and devastatingly handsome young man named James.  She and James, communicating with Thomas and Kate via their letter writing, encourage, narrate and help each other with their problems with deranged, psychopathic magicians.

The interesting thing is that each author is writes from one of the girl's point of view.  And they didn't sit out and plan out the story.  They just started writing the letters to each other, and the plot expanded out of that.  Wrede writes from Cecy's perspective, while Stevermer writes from Kate's. 

My favorite character has to be Thomas though.  I like him because he has some of the best one liners in the entire book (hilarious) and he is a good, well-rounded character.  He's obnoxious, rude and drives Kate and Cecy crazy, but means well.  He tells Kate during their first encounter, "Practice your dancing.  With enough study you might attain a degree of proficiency".  I won't say anymore because these characters are all well-rounded, well-thought out characters that you and students need to discover for themselves.

Okay, now on to my review.  This story is so cleverly written.  These girls were not the average young women found during the Regency time period (Kate gets in trouble for gilding her toe nails with gold).  But their spunk, wit, and intelligence is so endearing and fresh, it's impossible not to like these two heroines.  The story itself is about friendship, love, magic and commitment. 

This is definitely a book for students that are at a 7th grade reading level, at least.  There is a lot of vocabulary in the book that they may have a hard time with.  They also need to have a good understanding of point of view and setting.  They may need a little bit of a background knowledge of the time period.  Students that appreciate character development will especially enjoy this novel, since the strength of this book lies in the characters. 

I hope you enjoy Sorcery and Cecelia Or the Enchanted Chocolate Pot by Patricia Wrede and Caroline Stevermer as much as I do!